Report Summary for May 2026
This year: Fishing at Spinney Mountain Reservoir has offered varied success this month. While earlier in the month saw very solid fishing, particularly for wade and float tube anglers, the past week has been a little slower, with shore fishing becoming tougher. The best action has generally been found earlier/mid-morning and late afternoon. The lake remains very low, which has made some of the usual spots harder to access. Effective techniques include static indicator nymphing and slow crawling flies. Tandem indicator rigs fished 2-8 feet down have been productive, with success often found by bumping flies occasionally. Streamer fishing is also a key method, especially when covering water or targeting cruising fish. Look for flats or drop-offs, and be prepared to cover ground or use a personal watercraft to access more productive areas. Fish are feeding at varied depths, with many finding success in the 4-7 foot range. Chironomids have been hatching in good numbers, providing steady action for a couple of hours. Anglers are also seeing leeches, scuds, and egg patterns bringing fish to the net, with increased Callibaetis activity expected as we move into June. Recommended patterns include the Red Assassin, Clearwater Pupa, Meat Whistle, and Baby Gonga.
Best time of day: All day
Prior years: Fishing quality is good this month, with clear water conditions and the lake level around 53%. Anglers are finding success covering water and sight fishing to cruising fish along edges and drop-offs. Many fish cruise in packs, actively foraging. Two primary rigging styles are proving effective: static nymphing and streamer fishing. When nymphing, carry a static indicator rig with a combination of balanced leeches, eggs, chironomid larva, and scuds. Set your indicator to match the observed depth of the fish. Early in the month, only non-motorized vessels and wade fishing are permitted. Ramps for motorized vessels typically open later in May.
This report combines publicly available data when available with our own analysis to give a comprehensive view of the stream conditions.
Recommended patterns

Mini Leech Jig

Silvey's Balanced Sculpin

Catskill Dry

Red Fox Squirrel Nymph

Bomber chironomid

Bullethead Baitfish
The lake is currently very low, making some usual spots harder to access. Motorized boats will not be allowed this year, and the main boat ramps may not be opening soon. Personal watercraft like float tubes and kayaks are recommended to reach more areas. There are two boat ramps and several parking areas available, with a $9.00 daily pass fee. Be aware that boats are inspected for Zebra Mussels.
• Winds could get intense with thunderstorms.
• Motorized boats will not be allowed this year.
Rate this report
Your feedback helps us improve stream reports.
Looks good
Needs attention





